American Idol fans

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by zomo

Who I think is going home will be between Luke Menard Garret Haley. They both didn't get a lot of exposure and I feel they have the weakest vocals.

I have to agree with this! I feel that they don't give the exposure to the people they know won't go as far as others! But they could prove us wrong. Who knows. I think they had the weakest performances last night though.

Originally Posted by zomo

I really like Michel John, Jason Castro(Dreadlocks),David Acheleta( 17 year old).

I think Jason Castro is really really good too! And I don't remember seeing him in the auditions. Do you?

Originally Posted by zomo

I feel Colton Berry (Ellen Degeneris look alike ) will really surprise us.

He did have a nice voice. But people may find his personality a little over the top! I was a little annoyed (awful to say, I know...)

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by zomo

I don't believe I saw Jason Castro I would have remembered him. He"s a charmer.
I know what you mean about Colton Berrys personality but I try to overlook that and just listen to them sing.I often turn away and listen so I can truly hear their voice. If they are too good looking or annoying it distracts me. So here goes for the girls. Ramiele was my number one girl with Carly (irish) right behind her Asia Epperson was very good too. And Syesha was on her game. I pick Kristy Lee Cook (she sold her horse ) and Amy Davis to leave.

I agree hands down with everything you just said! You've got the same top girls that I've chosen too! But I have to add that I really like Brooke (curly blonde). She didn't do so hot tonight (mediocre)... but her auditions were outstanding. I was disappointed tonight. I'm hoping she sticks around because she's very good!

And yes... Jason Castro is a charmer, isn't he??? I could do w/out the dreds! But he's got a killer look to him!

[kayboxer]

Oh man, I can't remember the girls name! I pick the rocker chick, (I think she will show a lot more later on), the one who's dad died right before she auditioned, she was really good, the one with the big hair (african/american gal who lost her voice in Hollywood), and the Irish gal. Those are my favs that I can think of right now. Next time I'm writing names!

[elindave]

Originally Posted by kayboxer

Oh man, I can't remember the girls name! I pick the rocker chick, (I think she will show a lot more later on), the one who's dad died right before she auditioned, she was really good, the one with the big hair (african/american gal who lost her voice in Hollywood), and the Irish gal. Those are my favs that I can think of right now. Next time I'm writing names!

I'm rooting for the same girls!!

Eli
Nikita (Aug 28 07) fawn, floppy, docked

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by zomo

Ok I did take notes they are kind of sketchy but hope this helps ya all
Kristy Lee Cook (sold her horse)
Joanne Borgella ( + size model)
Alaina Whitaker ( Youngest and really likes shoes)
Amanda Overmyer (Rocker Chick)
Amy Davis ( All I had was really bad pitch)She didn't like the judges remarks
Brooke White ( Carly Simon look alike)
Alexandrea Lushington ( Wore Peace Earing)Always has a lot of family support
Kady Meloy(Britney Spears imitation)
AsiaH Epherson ( Dad died during auditions)
Ramiele Malabay ( Teeny one with big voice)
Syesha Marcote( big hair Bigger smile)
Carly Smithson ( Irish)
Sorry for the misspelled names Zoe and Melvin were shopping for something to get into Had to keep an eye on them.

Oh... check this out!!!! You are good!

So what do you feel about the ones sent home tonight????

I have to admit... the two girls (JoAnn and Amy) who went home tonight were predictable after last nights performances. I wasn't surprised to see (Garrett go home). And as much as I was annoyed by Colton, I thought he'd stick around for a while because he had a good voice.

[kayboxer]

Originally Posted by zomo

Ok I did take notes they are kind of sketchy but hope this helps ya all
Kristy Lee Cook (sold her horse)
Joanne Borgella ( + size model)
Alaina Whitaker ( Youngest and really likes shoes)
Amanda Overmyer (Rocker Chick)
Amy Davis ( All I had was really bad pitch)She didn't like the judges remarks
Brooke White ( Carly Simon look alike)
Alexandrea Lushington ( Wore Peace Earing)Always has a lot of family support
Kady Meloy(Britney Spears imitation)
AsiaH Epherson ( Dad died during auditions)
Ramiele Malabay ( Teeny one with big voice)
Syesha Marcote( big hair Bigger smile)
Carly Smithson ( Irish)
Sorry for the misspelled names Zoe and Melvin were shopping for something to get into Had to keep an eye on them.

You were on the ball! Okay, is Brooke White the one with the long curly blonde hair who looks like she should be in a granola commercial?

[kayboxer]

Originally Posted by Chiefsmom

I have to admit... the two girls (JoAnn and Amy) who went home tonight were predictable after last nights performances. I wasn't surprised to see (Garrett go home). And as much as I was annoyed by Colton, I thought he'd stick around for a while because he had a good voice.

I wasn't surprised with the girls at all. I think the bigger gal (Joanne Borgella?) would have stayed had she had a better song choice, I think she actually had a good voice. She just happened to pick the wrong music I think. I thought the kid with the short blonde hair didn't do that bad, he did sort of surprise me. I kind of like him, better than the Leif Garrett look alike, I didn't like him at all.

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by kayboxer

You were on the ball! Okay, is Brooke White the one with the long curly blonde hair who looks like she should be in a granola commercial?

Yep. that would be her! I think she is very good from her auditions (but I wasn't impressed with last nights performance).

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by kayboxer

I wasn't surprised with the girls at all. I think the bigger gal (Joanne Borgella?) would have stayed had she had a better song choice, I think she actually had a good voice. She just happened to pick the wrong music I think.

I agree.... I think that had Joanne picked a better song choice, she'd still be there!

[kayboxer]

Okay, could Paula's voice sound anymore fake than in her video? You can tell they definately did some work on it with equipment. It didn't sound natural at all!

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by kayboxer

Okay, could Paula's voice sound anymore fake than in her video? You can tell they definately did some work on it with equipment. It didn't sound natural at all!

That's what I thought!!!!!! It sounded so "robotic" and altered! And from all those stories on the news of her being on so many pain meds from back pain (resulting in her "aloofness"), she certainly appeared perfectly fine with the way she was dancing around just as she used to!

[kayboxer]

Originally Posted by zomo

Well what I think is that it was predictable for Amy and Garett but I was surprised and disappointed to see Joanne and Colton because I thought they had superior voices than some that are still left. I guess what I forget is these things really are both singing contest and popularity contest. And for Paula I can't even say that I heard her voice the song was mixed and remixed so much. I would like to see her sing on Idol without all of that. And Simon"s last comments to Colton were just mean. Did you see his parents ? They were so upset. I think this kid would be great in musical theatre.

I missed that part. I don't understand why he had to say mean comments though, they are being voted off anyway and to be the first one voted off has to be hard enough, then to hear mean comments. Talk about stepping on someone when they are down. I like Simon, but not when he does stuff like that.