American Idol fans

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by beausmommy

I think Luke, Danny, Kristy and Kady will be going home tonight but that's just my guess!

I have to agree 100%! Kristy might stay; but I can't think of who else would go.

My fave girls are Carly and Brooke!
And guys the two Davids.

[caruse]

I agree about A'siah, Zomo.....all bets off now...the season starts now!!!...Barbara

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by zomo

Final four guys not in order: Jason Castro, David Hernandez,David Cook,David Aucheleta.
Final four girls not in order: Brooke White, Carly Smithson, Ramielle Malubay ,Amanda Overmyer
These are my predictions so they will all probably get kicked out real soon I don't have a very good record

I have to agree with all your choices except (don't hate me) I'm not a fan of Ramielle Malubay. I like Syesha Mercado (sp???) over Ramielle. But I think, overall, your predictions sound like mine. Especially with the guys!

[WeasleRocky]

as posted earlier... the boys 100% for sure... I think that will be the final 4 boys,,, the girls... all that matters is that Carly is there in my book... I WANT HER TO GO ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!! she's got a beautiful voice that can really belt out the songs... GO CARLY!!!

[kayboxer]

I was so mad that Asiah was voted off, I wanted Syesha (sp?) to go. I think she believes she is so much better than she actually is and I think she is just a bit too conceded for my taste. I loved Asiah's soulful voice, it kind of reminded me of Alisha Keys. I want a recount!

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by WeasleRocky

all that matters is that Carly is there in my book... I WANT HER TO GO ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!! she's got a beautiful voice that can really belt out the songs... GO CARLY!!!

I agree. She's got an amazing voice! I like Brooke white too. They're my top 2for the girls! But Carly can def. out-sing Brooke.

Originally Posted by zomo

I am so disappointed to see Asiah leave Idol. I thought that everyone did so much better this week overall. Now the real season starts. Game on!

I was also disappointed to see Asiah leave. She did really well and I don't think she got enough credit for that song. Whitney songs are tough! I think she did better than Syesha this week.

[StormiesMom]

Sorry to be such a "meanie" here, but I am SO GLAD to see Noriega go home. I was not ready to deal with another "Sanjaya" issue, LOL.

I was a bit surprised to see Asia'h go home, though, she is so adorable and has a lovely kinda fun raspy voice - she would have continued to get better too.

[K8IE]

I was also sad to see Asiah go, she did have a very unique voice and seemed so sweet. I can't wait to see what this week will bring!! I have to say, I was very happy to see the guys that went go.. Oh, and Kady. They all were on my last nerve!!!

[Chiefsmom]

Originally Posted by StormiesMom

Sorry to be such a "meanie" here, but I am SO GLAD to see Noriega go home.

You and me both! He was so obnoxious! (yep... I'm being a meanie too)! But he thought his s#*t didn't stink! LOL

[Chiefsmom]

Okay......... So thoughts on tonights performances?????????

Loved: Carly Smithson again (Irish girl w/ tattoo); Brooke White ( on keyboard); And the two daves are still my faves even though they both goofed this week! Otherwise, I thought Jason Carpenter (long dread-locks) did very very well!

Opinions? Predictions?

[ForeverMama]

Was disappointed in David A.'s performance. Thought Chikesie, Carly, Brooke and Amanda did great. Think Kristy or Ramiele will be going home even though David A. forgot some of his words. I think his previous performances will keep him in there.

[beausmommy]

My favorites last night were Brooke White and Jason Castro simply because I think their voices are well-suited for the songs they chose. David Cook is starting to grow on me. Maybe it's because I'm a crossword junkie, too I had to fast forward through Kristy Lee Cook's song. It was excruciatingly awful in my opinion and I'm a big country music fan!