Something has furiated me!

[l0v1n6b0x3r5]

I was reading under the Transport Forum and someone had mentioned the Canine Underground Railroad. I hadn't heard of this so I looked it up and found the following article:

DawnWatch: LA Times lengthy front page story on Canine Underground Railroad 8/24/05

The front page of the Wednesday, August 24, Los Angeles Times has a superb article, that extends over three pages, headed "Riding the Underground Railroad." It follows the journey of Paddy, "a mid-size, aging brown mutt" from Tennessee, from where a rescuer closing down shop posted his photo on the Internet, to his new home in California. He changes hands many times on his 2,260 mile, 60 hour, drive across the country.

The article is written with tenderness -- I found myself almost moved to tears by the efforts of so many people to save one dog. But it asks the hard questions. For example, we meet Deanna Trietsch, 44, who "regularly gives last walks to strays about to be euthanized in public shelters, to 'make their last hours feel like they were loved,'" and who is part of the Paddy express. We read:

"Still, she found Paddy's odyssey a little puzzling. 'I do wonder why somebody in California would want to bring this dog all the way across the country. Quite frankly, I'm sure I could have found an animal I loved right here in Tennessee. Why wouldn't you search your local area? But they must've seen something in this pretty fella.' As she spoke, about 250 dogs needing homes were being housed at the shelter in Orange County. Most would end up euthanized."

And we read:

"Some animal welfare organizations question the need for the marathon relays, noting that people can easily adopt from nearby shelters. An estimated 3 million to 6 million cats and dogs are still euthanized nationally each year, according to the Humane Society of the United States. Those numbers are down from 20 years ago, when about 17 million stray dogs and cats were destroyed annually. The organizations worry that it is stressful for animals to be hauled long distances, and wonder who monitors them during their journeys and afterward."

The article tells us: "But transporters say there are many reasons for far-flung adoptions. People sometimes can't find a certain breed in their region, so they look farther afield. Finding homes for older or disabled animals can be difficult within a small range. And there are sharp regional disparities in the number of available pets."

Still, that hardly explains why people would devote such effort to bringing a "a mid-size, aging brown mutt" to a city that kills 60,000 dogs every year for lack of homes.

The story does not have a joyous ending. The woman who is choosing to import the mixed breed from the other end of the country seems strange. We read of Paddy's new home:

"The acrid smell of dog and cat urine cut through the night air. Inside, a frenetic chorus of barking and hissing came from behind a closed door. Three sick kittens with rheumy eyes lay curled up in a fleece basket. Paddy was joining Meddick's menagerie, which already included 26 animals in the 900-square-foot house and backyard, including a litter of puppies. Four dogs were stacked in crates covered with blankets. Meddick said she crates some of them when she is away on rescues and transports, which can take as long as 14 hours. The living room had little furniture or indoor lighting. Paddy squeezed himself into a narrow hiding place between the front door and a stack of boxes. Meddick lay down next to him and talked softly. Along with her unfamiliar non-Southern accent were the familiar sounds and smells of many animals in a confined space. 'It beats the alternative: being put to death at a shelter,' Meddick said. Within minutes of ending his transcontinental journey, Padd y was in a crate, his eyes peering into the dark."

Those who had cared for Paddy in Tennessee and set him on his journey to his new home wrote and asked for pictures and information but his new caretaker feels his welfare is none of their business. They are left to wonder how much of his life Paddy spends, 2,000 miles out of their reach, in a crate.

The article brings home the importance of spay-neuter, with Annette Rauch of the Tufts University School of Veterinary Medicine commenting:
"We have some areas of the country now where we've done enough spay and neutering that you really don't have surplus puppies and kittens. In other parts of the country, she says, things are grim."

And it includes some touching lines, such as those from a woman who "decided to work with animals rather than the elderly or children after consulting her Bible." In her words: "It said, 'The man who cares for his domestic animals is blessed. God gave man dominion over the animals.' So I said OK, I'm doing animals…. They are not masters of their fate; they're just floating along in the human deal."

So my question is, why would this person have left his poor dog with this dog-horder? This angers me and makes me sad to think that this sad pup spent the last few years/months of his life in a hell-hole, dirty, smelly, place. My heart cries out for these babies...

[RoxysMum]

Makes you kind of wonder if the poor thing would have been better off being euthanized. It's truely sad when that's the question being asked.

[Indy B's Mom]

That is awful and strange. How scary for that poor baby. I agree with you-why didn't the transporter turn around and walk away? That makes me want to cry.

[l0v1n6b0x3r5]

I totally agree! I would have turned around and took the dog back home... with me. I would have kept the poor mut until we could find a home for him... poor guy!

[bucca]

i read the article twice and correct me if im wrong but isnt the way those animals are living considered abuse? and why is this person still in the possesion of animals? where is law enforcement or the local animal patrol ? it made me sick and as for the transporter how can you sleep at night leaving that innocent animal there and not to mention the rest of the animals in that place.

[WaitingOnAce]

I felt sick as I read this story, but felt compelled to write. I rescued Grace from a shelter in Georgia and volunteers drove her all the way to Maine. Was it worth it? Absolutely!!! She is an amazing animal and deserves to live. I am located in a very rural area and there is no Boxer Rescue in my state. While there is a rescue in New England, travel would still be required to get a dog to me. We do not have kill shelters in my area, so the notion of dogs being euthanized so often was foreign to me. I needed Grace as much as she needed me.

I have become friends with the girl in GA who helped this girl get her forever home. We remain in contact and I send her pix of Gracie happy and healthy.

There are people everywhere who do not provide the love and security that animals deserve. I believe that the person in the story was an example of the exception. More often, a family willing to take in a pet (often sick or needing costly treatment) is a caring one.

I love the Canine Underground Railroad, and the volunteers who brought Grace to her forever home. Sometimes a story like mine restores faith in humanity and reminds me that people care.

Sorry this got so long,

Em & Grace

[sminoleboxer]

Emily, thanks for your reply. I agree that this story was awful and should have had a different ending. I also would have not left that pup there. But, like you stated this is not the norm. Most of the CUR runs are done for the good of the animal. I have seen people be raked over the coals and ridiculed because they were doing a run across the country for an animal. They were suspected of being just like the woman in this story even though most of the time they are going to a home like yours where they are very much wanted and cared for. I would like to ask this reporter to follow another run with a more typical ending. CUR is great in my opinion. I would participate anytime, believing in the best outcome, and if that is not what I found at the end then turn around and take the baby back with me! if we believe in the best of people we help make it happen. If we believe in the worst of people that is what we will find!